My daughter, light of my life, just missed the honor roll once. One half-grade better, and she was in the Promised Land. When I found out, I didn’t chew her out, though our conversation did get crunchy. Tired of it after a while, she hit me with this: “Like you never got a bad grade in high school?”
First, her question was off. Her own grade wasn’t bad. Talking about the qualities of “bad” with her for a moment helped me to evade the main component of her kind-of inquiry: “Like,” hadn’t I received a bad grade in my career?
In fact, I did receive bad grades – not borderline grades – in my school career. I’m not talking “Developing,” “Average,” “On-your-merry-way-with-a-little-effort-so-here’s-a-trophy.” I’m talking Failing. Inadequate. Unsatisfactory.
I didn’t tell her that at the moment, though. When she smelled an opportunity, teenage predator that she now is, and the pressure got too intense, I used my go-to parenting trick and ran out of the room.
The guilt since that conversation has eaten at me a bit though. As I sit here, a person who has written two books, a PhD in English, a job as a writing professor and director of the writing center at an outstanding university, a person who reads Pynchon for fun and writes this really cool blog, I couldn’t tell her, could I? I couldn’t reveal that among my bad grades, my academic stumblings, I, I …
I got a D in freshman English in high school.
Maybe if I told her I could argue that I was a late bloomer (citing Gladwell [1] and some prime examples [2]), even though the reality is that I was a dumb lazyass when I got that D. Maybe I could say that my hard-won pain is what I’m trying to help her avoid, although the pain was minimal and I somehow righted my grades and go on track later, in college and grad school.
So should I have told her? What does a kid do with that information from ma or pa? Feel better? Feel vindicated? Develop an excuse for sloth? She would likely use it to launch total ad hominem attacks: “How can you, get on my back about grades!” she might shriek, Macbeth witch-like. “You got a D in freshman English and are now an English professor! Gaahhh!”
I’m not going to use my already small readership for group therapy, so I won’t get into all of the other things I won’t tell her probably ever, the iniquities, poor judgments, the crimes …
Let’s just say some things are better left unsaid. Your late bloomerness (again, in many cases probably your stupid lazyassness) may make for a great Oprah story, but to your kids, it might be fuel, ammunition. They may even think less of us, confusing their perception of the heroic god-dad, and thus ruining our ability to deliver advice and commandments.
Obviously this gets way more complicated than grades.
Why put them through that? So my frosh D in English stays with us, okay? I have decided not to tell her – not just yet, at least.
- Author Bio [3]
- Latest Posts [4]
Scott Warnock [6]
Latest posts by Scott Warnock (Posts [7])
- Competitive disparity has sapped my interest in NJ high school wrestling [8] - March 16, 2025
- Bros want control, responsibility–let’s make some abortion laws to help ‘em [9] - December 19, 2024
- The NFL is here and my kids finally care [10] - September 27, 2024
- Who really won the Olympics? [11] - August 30, 2024
- Watching the Olympics is good for you–AND Flavor Flav’s on board? [12] - July 26, 2024