Just Fantastic: Dungeons and Dragons 4th Edition
Dungeons & Dragons (D&D) is in its fourth edition (but fifth incarnation) since 1974. I’ve played three incarnations: 2nd, 3.5, and 4th. I’ve got to say that the fourth edition does one thing very well.
For anyone unfamiliar, a table top role-playing game (RPG), like D&D, uses a pen, character sheet(s), a series of books, and a set of dice. The set of dice consists of: 1 four-sided, 1 six-sided, 2 ten-sided, 1 twelve-sided, and 1 twenty-sided die. Dice are also abbreviated “D” as in D20 for a twenty-sided die. You might laugh at this now, but one day you’ll be in a comic shop on the wrong side of the tracks and knowing what a D20 is might help you make a saving throw against a band of asthmatic angry nerds.
D&D, and similar RGPs, are played with one person running the world and a group of players going through the world. The concept is that the players will have their characters act according to their personalities and shared experiences. For example, a brooding solitary dwarf will warm up and make friends with the plucky tiefling after they save each other’s lives from a nest of giant spiders. Or as is more common with my current D&D 4th edition group, they will buy each other prostitutes once they return to town.
RPGs are as much a part of comic culture as comics themselves because they share space in the same shops. While there are purists, comic readers who hate RPG-ers and vice versa, for the most part anyone into one has at least tried the other. In fact I became interested in comics because I was into Star Wars RPG as a teenager.
The 4th edition D&D is a great miniatures game. The publisher, Wizards of the Coast, has taken a lot of the ambiguity out of the game by instituting a standard series of measurements. This sound logical, but is a huge shift away from 3.5 D&D where things were vague and left to the discretion of the dungeon master, or DM. (A DM is responsible for making the world around the players.) In 3.5, a player would need to ask the DM if he or she could do something; now the player simply counts squares.
While many old school D&D players and DMs are unhappy with the shift, I happen to love it. Currently, I am the DM for a monthly group of mid-twenty-somethings. Not forcing the DM (me) to make a nit-picky decision every twenty seconds, and not forcing the players to ask a nit-picky question every twenty seconds, allows us to focus on the role-playing aspect of the game.
I would say the band of greedy anti-heroes I’m DM-ing now is the best its ever been strictly because the new rules let them focus. I’ve actually seen players do things that are completely illogical from a tactical standpoint because they’re so focused on their role. It’s a beautiful thing for a DM to watch and makes all those hours spent building dungeons pay off.
So my hat goes off to you, Wizards of the Coast, for a ballsy shift in the RPG paradigm that really paid off.
Print This Post
About Steve Mazzeo
Abusive comments may be deleted and abusive commenters may be banned. See comment policies.




Steve, good post … brought back a lot of happy memories of whiling-away my spare time in college with ongoing games of D&D. This was 35 years ago, so I guess I would definitely count as “old school” … I know our materials (with guidance from Gygax’ manuals) would appear primitive - to say the least! - today.